Sounds like Yaldabaoth wasn't that far off when he pretended to be Igor.

Yaldabaoth also wanted to control humans too, which makes sense since he was the god of control. He manipulated a lot of things to guide me and other humans into "ruin". Even tried to make a deal with me where he would give me and the other Phantom Thieves power while he controlled over everyone else in the real world.

I said no of course. People can change and they aren't just mindless sheep that would rather be controlled than think for themselves, or even care for others.